Skip to main content

‘Carolina Caroline’ Uses Red, White, and Blue to Chart an American Dream Gone Rogue

Fashion

Costume designers Anaïs Castaldi and Hannah Greenblatt break down the film’s playful Americana-inspired wardrobe, from Caroline’s sunshiny early looks to the increasingly bold disguises she adopts as her life takes a wild turn.

In Adam Rehmeier’s romantic crime caper “Carolina Caroline,” a listless young woman leaves her dead-end job stocking shelves at a Texas gas station for a life on the road with a charismatic con man. That soon turns into a life on the run for Caroline (Samara Weaving) and her beau Oliver (Kyle Gallner), who scale up from small-town shoplifting to full-on scams and bank heists.

From their very first read of the script, costume designers Anaïs Castaldi and Hannah Greenblatt began thinking in color. The film operates within a red, white, and blue Americana palette that Rehmeier favors across his work, but within that framework, each character was assigned their own color. For Oliver, who keeps a cool head no matter what situation he's in, that meant predominantly dressing him in blues. Caroline, meanwhile, comes to represent red but is actually first associated with yellow. “She's our yellow for sunshine, and then later she's our red for passion and love,” Greenblatt explains. Those colors become a visual shorthand for Caroline's transformation, charting her journey from a wide-eyed and innocent small-town girl to a woman swept up in the intoxicating thrill of a life sustained on ill-gotten gains.

When we first meet Caroline in the film's opening, she's dressed in a vintage graphic T-shirt, blue jeans, and a touch of yellow. It's an intentionally youthful combination, reflecting a character who hasn't yet had the chance to experience much beyond her immediate surroundings. “She's a very naive character,” says Greenblatt. “She's young. She hasn't seen the world, and Oliver really comes in like a tornado.” The yellow was chosen to represent this purity instead of the obvious choice of white, which Castaldi and Greenblatt felt was too overused and predictable. T The same shade resurfaces later when Caroline tracks down her estranged mother (played by Kyra Sedgwick). Her yellow flannel is a deliberate return to something familiar. “That yellow flannel is kind of her slice of home and comfort,” Greenblatt says. Even as Caroline's world expands, the color offers a reminder of the girl she was before Oliver.

Samara Weaving and Kyle Gallner in "Carolina Caroline".

Magnolia Pictures

Red is where Caroline is headed. The first glimpse of it comes in a rather intimate way: Caroline's red lingerie, which she strips down to for her and Oliver’s skinny-dipping adventure after their first date. The designers considered a white alternative and black felt too stark, while red offered a more suggestive introduction to the color that would eventually come to define her. “There's something underneath her. There's a little fire under everything else,” says Greenblatt. As Caroline embraces her new life, red gradually works its way into her everyday wardrobe. When she leaves home with Oliver, for instance, she's wearing denim cut-offs and a red-and-white striped shirt. It's not quite the full-blown red wardrobe we'll see later, but the color is beginning to take hold. As their romance intensifies, so does the presence of red, reflecting the danger of their increasingly risky escapades.

The designers also wanted Caroline's wardrobe to feel like an actual wardrobe, rather than a succession of pristine, one-off movie outfits. “We really like to develop characters when we can and almost like build people a wardrobe,” Greenblatt explains. “Think about you and your everyday life. You have your favorite pair of jeans. You wear them a ton.” Oliver is a particularly good example of this approach: he wears the same denim jacket and pair of jeans throughout much of the film, an understated choice that helps make him feel like a real person.

Samara Weaving in costume for "Carolina Caroline".

Magnolia Pictures

Kyle Gallner in costume for "Carolina Caroline".

Magnolia Pictures

Samara Weaving in costume for "Carolina Caroline".

Magnolia Pictures

The film's deliberately ambiguous period gave the designers room to play. Although its lack of cell phones places it firmly in a pre-millennium world, “Carolina Caroline” never pins itself to a specific year. That meant Castaldi and Greenblatt could draw from several decades of American cinema, taking inspiration from the crime thrillers, road movies, romances, and bank-heist films of the 1970s, '80s, and '90s. For Oliver, that translated into a classic heartthrob formula: white T-shirts, denim, and the kind of effortless appeal associated with Paul Newman, Robert Redford, and Harrison Ford. “It never gets old,” Greenblatt says. Castaldi adds that they initially looked at images of Ford in particular, including his Canadian tuxedo and white undershirt-and-jeans combinations.

The production's Kentucky location proved useful for sourcing, too. While much of the film was prepped in Los Angeles, the designers also had the opportunity to shop locally and tap into the area's more distinctive Western wear. Castaldi recalls the advantage of having access to both the enormous LA costume warehouses and the smaller shops and thrift stores they encountered while filming. That hands-on approach paid off spectacularly for one of the film's most memorable sequences: the bank robberies. The designers immediately saw an opportunity in the script's five heists, imagining a red, white, and blue wardrobe montage that would take Rehmeier's Americana aesthetic to its most exuberant extreme. It wasn't necessarily written into the script, but they were determined to make it happen. “We were like, ‘Adam, we have to do this, we have to do this, we have to do this,’” Greenblatt recalls. It took some convincing, but the designers eventually got their way.

The result is a series of deliberately larger-than-life disguises that feel worlds away from Caroline's usual clothes. There's the oversized American flag jacket she wears during the first robbery, paired with a wig and sunglasses, as well as a more dramatic, dark vinyl-looking trench coat in other heist scenes. The flag jacket was particularly special: the designers found a version in a costume house that wasn't quite the right size, then worked with their assistant costume designer, Molly Morgan, to recreate it from scratch. Morgan is an expert seamstress, and her skills proved invaluable in getting the fit just right.

Samara Weaving in "Carolina Caroline".

Magnolia Pictures

Kyle Gallner in "Carolina Caroline".

Magnolia Pictures

Caroline's mother, meanwhile, gets a very different kind of wardrobe treatment. Despite appearing in just one scene, Sedgwick's character is given a fully realized look that tells us plenty about the life she's been living. “She's wearing leather pants, she's wearing a cowboy boot, she's wearing a red bra and a torn-up animal-print top with a cross around her neck,” Greenblatt says. “You know, she's a Southern woman who maybe has gone to church before in her life. I don't know if she still does. I think she kind of lives at the bar now.”

Castaldi agrees that, given the character's limited screen time, the wardrobe needed to do some heavy lifting. The animal print and revealing layers also suggest a woman who still wants to feel sexy, holding on to a sense of youth and identity. Sedgwick, for her part, threw herself into the role, even requesting that her fingernails look stained from years of smoking, Greenblatt recalls. “She just came in truly like a tornado,” she says. “We all were in awe.”

By the time Caroline reaches the film's final stretch, the fiery red that once defined her has begun to fade. Burgundy and black creep into the wardrobe as her circumstances grow darker and the consequences of her actions begin to catch up with her. Even the yellow makes a brief return, this time in the form of an eagle-emblazoned shirt. Rehmeier, Greenblatt notes, loves a nod to an eagle, but the designers also saw an opportunity to bring back a color associated with Caroline's former life. There's almost a longing for home in it, or for the innocence she can no longer quite reclaim. “That flame is dying for sure,” Greenblatt says.

For her final look, as Caroline prepares to leave for Ecuador, the designers offer one last, quieter character detail: a denim jacket that, while not literally meant to be Oliver’s, is meant to remind us of him—and his wardrobe. “That's a nod to Oliver with the jean jacket,” Greenblatt says. “It's not his per se because he leaves her wearing his so she doesn't physically have that jacket, but it's sort of a little nod to him.”


You might also like this